top of page

Build New or Buy a Fixer-Upper? How Modular Construction Changes the Comparison

Sep 11
5 min read

If you’re looking for a new home in Central Pennsylvania, you may be weighing two choices: buy an older home and remodel it, or build a brand-new home. There are pros and cons to each.


Remodeling could make sense if you love an established neighborhood and want to preserve an older home's character. However, building new lets you customize your home from the start and helps reduce legacy problems often associated with older homes (outdated HVACs, cramped living areas, poor insulation, etc.).


But another option is worth considering: building a new modular home. For example, at Designer Homes of Pennsylvania, we build each new modular home with quality materials, skilled craftsmanship, and highly efficient construction methods that rival traditional site-built homes (and often at a lower price point).


Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of buying a fixer-upper house compared to buying a new modular home.


When Does Remodeling an Existing Home Make Sense?


If you find an older home in your favorite Central Pennsylvania neighborhood and you like most of its basic layout, remodeling may be a practical choice. You may be able to preserve the details you love while updating a kitchen, bathroom, flooring, or other specific areas.


Buying a fixer-upper makes sense if:


  • The home’s structure and major systems are in good condition (HVAC, plumbing, electrical, etc.).

  • Your home remodel project is relatively limited in scope.

  • You want to preserve the home’s existing character and layout.


However, if you’re considering buying a home that requires extensive renovations, you may want to compare the time and costs of a remodel to building a new home, such as modular construction.


The Purchase Price Is Only the Starting Point for an Existing Home


Many new home buyers mistakenly assume a resale house is less expensive than building a new one. But ask yourself, “What will my costs be after closing?”

Maybe the tiny kitchen needs a complete reconfiguration. Perhaps the bathrooms are dated, the flooring needs replacing, or there isn’t enough storage. An older home may also need updates to windows, insulation, HVAC equipment, plumbing, electrical systems, or roofing.


Older homes can also come with challenges that you may not discover until remodeling work begins. Once contractors open walls, ceilings, or floors, they may find conditions that weren’t apparent at the start of the project. Those discoveries can affect both the budget and your construction schedule.


This means older homes aren’t always less expensive than new construction, according to NewHomeSource. Costs can vary considerably, depending on the renovation scope, location, desired features, and problems discovered during construction.


And with today’s new modular homes, construction costs are often up to 15% lower than new site-built homes. If you’re looking at a fixer-upper that requires extensive renovations, your cost can exceed that of a brand-new modular home.


Building New Gives You More Customization From the Beginning


With remodeling, you have to start with someone else’s floor plan and try to make it work for your lifestyle.


  • Want a bigger kitchen? You may need to remove walls.

  • Need a walk-in pantry? You have to find space for it.

  • Want a first-floor primary suite? That could require an addition.


With a new modular home from Designer Homes of Pennsylvania, we can customize your floor plan and features to fit the lifestyle you want. And our efficient, climate-controlled factory construction process is why our homes are often less expensive and faster to build compared to traditional, site-built houses.


Need a home office, better storage, wider hallways, a larger bathroom, or a more open living area? We offer more than 300 customizable floor plans ranging from approximately 1,000 to 4,000 square feet, including ranch, Cape Cod, and two-story designs. You can then personalize your home with hundreds of options for kitchens, cabinets, countertops, flooring, fixtures, siding, shingles, and other details.


Instead of spending money undoing someone else’s choices, you can put that investment toward creating the home you actually want.


Can Building a New Modular Home Be as Fast as Remodeling?


Yes! In many cases, building a new modular home can be less time-consuming than an extensive renovation project. Many homebuyers assume remodeling will automatically be faster because the house already exists. But that isn’t always the case.


As we noted earlier, a whole-house remodel may involve demolition, structural changes, electrical, and plumbing updates. This may include inspections, additions, new finishes, and coordinating multiple contractors. Unexpected conditions can also add time along the way.


At Designer Homes, we build most of the home indoors in a climate-controlled factory while work at the homesite can proceed at the same time. So, site preparation and foundation work don’t have to wait for the home itself to be framed.


Our modular construction process can be approximately 30% to 50% faster than traditional site-built construction, and many of our projects can be completed in about six months.


Building New Can Increase Your Home’s Energy Efficiency


You can increase energy efficiency in an older home. But depending on its age, getting there may require replacing windows, adding insulation, improving air sealing, replacing HVAC equipment, or making other costly upgrades. 


With a new modular construction, you aren’t starting with decades-old building systems. Instead, your home starts with modern construction materials, current building requirements, and the chance to choose efficient systems and products from the start.


For example, Designer Homes uses ENERGY STAR® energy-efficient construction methods and materials. That can mean lower utility costs! Plus, a modular-designed building envelope with efficient heating and cooling can improve comfort throughout our cold Central Pennsylvania winters and warm summers.


Today’s Modular Construction Is Not the Same as Mobile and Manufactured Homes of the Past


Let’s clear up a common misconception in our industry: A modern modular home is not like an old-school manufactured or mobile home. Each of our modular homes is built in sections using conventional residential construction methods inside a controlled facility. We then transport these sections to your property, install them on a permanent foundation, join them, and complete the build on-site.


Advantages? For starters, building indoors protects materials from rain and snow during much of construction. Skilled craftsmen work in an organized factory environment in parallel, saving time and increasing efficiency. Quality inspections occur throughout production, minimizing weather delays.


This is the case for every Designer Home construction. As a division of the Ritz-Craft Corporation, a leader in modular housing since 1954, our construction experience combines factory efficiency with the craftsmanship and quality materials that buyers expect from a permanent new home.


Should You Remodel or Build a New Modular Home?


Either choice could be right for you, depending on your lifestyle and goals for your new dream home. 


  • Remodeling may be right for you if you love the home and location, the basic layout already works, major systems are sound, and the changes you want are relatively manageable.


  • Building a new modular home may make more sense if you want a more contemporary design, need more space, want a highly personalized home, or simply don’t want to spend money adapting an older house to your lifestyle.


Final Thoughts: Don’t Remodel Someone Else’s Home Until You Compare the Cost of Building Yours


Before you buy a fixer-upper, take time to research the advantages of new modular homes, starting with customization options for your home’s layout, features, materials, energy efficiency, and finishes.


At Designer Homes of Pennsylvania, we’ve built more than 300 homes in the region, with hundreds of customizable floor plans, personalization options, and a turnkey process designed to save time and money.


Visit our Photo Gallery or take a 3D tour of one of our new homes to see what modular construction looks like today. Or contact Designer Homes on our website or call us at 570-966-6244 to take the first step towards building a new home that’s truly yours from the beginning.

 
 
 

Comments


Central PA's Premiere Custom Modular Home Builder.

 

Designer Homes - a division of Ritz-Craft Corp. - is a leading custom modular home builder of ranch, cape and two-story homes in the Susquehanna River Valley of Central Pennsylvania. We are proud to offer over 300 custom modular home floor plans ranging in size from 1000 to 4000 square feet in the following areas: Mifflinburg, Lewisburg, Selinsgrove, Danville, Milton, Williamsport, Bloomsburg, State College, Jersey Shore and surrounding towns.

Designer Homes also builds duplex homes and townhouses as well as other types of prefabricated structures.

Home prices are determined by Designer Homes, who quotes all modular home costs on a turn-key basis. Custom modular home plans are also available.

Drawing on Ritz-Craft's 70 years of experience, we are proud to offer an extensive line of modular homes with hundreds of unique options - so you can personalize with ease and style. Through Ritz-Craft, Designer Homes is an Energy Star Partner and certified for Green Building. View our exterior renderings, modular home floor plans and interior pictures. Contact us for more information about building a Ritz-Craft home, designs, and mortgage loan financing options.

© 2024 by Designer Homes of PA. All rights reserved.

  • facebook
  • twitter
bottom of page